Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

meinereiner · 01-11-2013 20:25:49

Hello,

a new year, a new version, a new problem.

I've updated from packman to the new ffmpeg version 1.1 on opensuse 12.2 (I think I was a little bit crazy).

With the new devel-Version of your great program I got trouble with any sound in any video format.

In Terminal mode I got the message that the Audio conversion failed.

I think the ffmpeg-developer had changed a little bit at their input options.

Pherhaps you have an Idea?

Greetings

Norbert

domledom · 01-12-2013 07:00:13

Hello Norbert

For some time I started to redo my encoding engine.
In the next devel, the audio part will be redone.
Wait a few hours and retest with the devel I publish this week-end.

meinereiner · 01-13-2013 14:41:04

Helo,

the problem is still actual.

The message ist still standig, that the Audio conversion failed. I have paste a small part of the logfile.

Thats I think only a problem with the new 1.1 version of ffmpeg.

[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame => do a reformat of 2304 bytes audio data
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame => do a resample of 0 bytes
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendData
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::MixAppendPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendData
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:~cDiaporamaObjectInfo
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:cDiaporamaObjectInfo
[13:35:13.482:DEBUGTRACE] IN:DlgRenderVideo::EncodeMusic
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetObjectStartPosition
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:IsShotStatic
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:IsShotStatic
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadSources
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadTransitVideoImage
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareMusicBloc
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareImage
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadSourceVideoImage
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ImageAt
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareImage
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame => do a reformat of 4608 bytes audio data
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame => do a resample of 0 bytes
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendData
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::MixAppendPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendData
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:~cDiaporamaObjectInfo
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:DlgRenderVideo::EncodeMusic
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:cDiaporamaObjectInfo
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetObjectStartPosition
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:IsShotStatic
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:IsShotStatic
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadSources
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadTransitVideoImage
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareMusicBloc
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareImage
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadSourceVideoImage
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ImageAt
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareImage
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame
[13:35:13.483:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame => do a reformat of 4608 bytes audio data
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame => do a resample of 0 bytes
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendData
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::MixAppendPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendNullSoundPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendData
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::AppendPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:DlgRenderVideo::EncodeMusic
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:~cDiaporamaObjectInfo
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cSoundBlockList::DetachFirstPacket
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:cDiaporamaObjectInfo
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetObjectStartPosition
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:IsShotStatic
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporamaObjectInfo:IsShotStatic
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadSources
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareMusicBloc
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadTransitVideoImage
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:GetMusicObject
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareImage
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ImageAt
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:LoadSourceVideoImage
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame
[13:35:13.484:DEBUGTRACE] IN:cDiaporama:PrepareImage

Greetings

Norbert

meinereiner · 01-13-2013 16:44:54

Hllo again,

pherhaps it's possible that this is a special bug in the packman build

http://lists.links2linux.de/pipermail/p … 11692.html

I will wait.....

Norbert

meinereiner · 01-18-2013 18:47:53

Hello again,

in this post there seems to be a small solution for ffmpeg 1.1

http://lists.links2linux.de/pipermail/p … 11712.html

Greetings

Norbert

domledom · 01-18-2013 20:48:33

Hello Norbert

I think I've found the problem.
Try the 1.6 devel I will published this week-end and say me if it's ok.

meinereiner · 01-18-2013 22:33:39

Hello,

Thanks, I will try it. There is also movement at packman, who want to search for a solution for this problem this is breaking functionality for many other project with ffmpeg 1.1.

Temporarily they want to downgrade to 1.0.1. So if your solution is not a small workaround wait - if it is a great thing do it.... ;-))

Greetings

Norbert

meinereiner · 01-20-2013 15:47:36

Hello,

you are very busy with this project.

I've tested the version 363. The sound now will be converted but it sounds terrible. Is there any filter active? It is as if one is in a large hall.

Greetings

Norbert

domledom · 01-20-2013 16:24:35

Hello

I tested the app on Windows and Ubuntu without found this type of problem.
Could you send me the file to I hear it by myself

domledom · 01-26-2013 12:09:05

Hello

I've just published a new devel version that should fix the problem

meinereiner · 01-27-2013 12:02:10

Hello,

in the meantime packman has downgraded back to ffmpeg 1.0.1. So with the last version everything is OK except the soundexport only.

Now I have loaded the last version, and with the downgraded ffmpeg version I got compiling errors like this:

-------------------------------

cd src/ffDiaporama/ && make -f Makefile
make[1]: Entering directory `/usr/src/packages/SOURCES/ffDiaporama.r365/src/ffDiaporama'
g++ -c -m64 -pipe -O2 -D_REENTRANT -Wall -W -DHAVE_CONFIG_H -DTAGLIB_STATIC -DQ_OS_LINUX64 -DSHARE_DIR=\"/usr\" -DUSELIBAVRESAMPLE -DQT_NO_DEBUG -DQT_SVG_LIB -DQT_XML_LIB -DQT_GUI_LIB -DQT_NETWORK_LIB -DQT_CORE_LIB -DQT_SHARED -I/usr/share/qt4/mkspecs/default -I. -I/usr/include/QtCore -I/usr/include/QtNetwork -I/usr/include/QtGui -I/usr/include/QtXml -I/usr/include/QtSvg -I/usr/include -I/usr/include/ffmpeg/ -I../../../build/src/ffDiaporama -I../../../build/src/ffDiaporama -o ../../../build/src/ffDiaporama/cBaseMediaFile.o ../engine/cBaseMediaFile.cpp
../engine/cBaseMediaFile.cpp: In member function ‘virtual void cVideoFile::ReadAudioFrame(bool, qlonglong, cSoundBlockList*, double, bool)’:
../engine/cBaseMediaFile.cpp:1842:153: error: invalid conversion from ‘uint8_t** {aka unsigned char**}’ to ‘void**’ [-fpermissive]
In file included from ../engine/cDeviceModelDef.h:69:0,
from ../engine/cBaseMediaFile.h:38,
from ../engine/cBaseMediaFile.cpp:30:
/usr/include/libavresample/avresample.h:237:5: error: initializing argument 2 of ‘int avresample_convert(AVAudioResampleContext*, void**, int, int, void**, int, int)’ [-fpermissive]
../engine/cBaseMediaFile.cpp:1842:153: error: invalid conversion from ‘uint8_t** {aka unsigned char**}’ to ‘void**’ [-fpermissive]
In file included from ../engine/cDeviceModelDef.h:69:0,
from ../engine/cBaseMediaFile.h:38,
from ../engine/cBaseMediaFile.cpp:30:
/usr/include/libavresample/avresample.h:237:5: error: initializing argument 5 of ‘int avresample_convert(AVAudioResampleContext*, void**, int, int, void**, int, int)’ [-fpermissive]
make[1]: *** [../../../build/src/ffDiaporama/cBaseMediaFile.o] Error 1
make[1]: Leaving directory `/usr/src/packages/SOURCES/ffDiaporama.r365/src/ffDiaporama'
make: *** [sub-src-ffDiaporama-make_default] Error 2

---------------------------

And now....?

domledom · 01-27-2013 16:53:54

Hello

They had better not downgrade like that: they have put to an intermediate version.
Wich version have you exactly now ?

meinereiner · 01-27-2013 20:24:07

Hello,

they have downgraded to

ffmpeg version 1.0.1
built on Jan 20 2013 21:32:11 with gcc 4.7 (SUSE Linux)
configuration: --shlibdir=/usr/lib64 --prefix=/usr --mandir=/usr/share/man --libdir=/usr/lib64 --enable-shared --disable-static --enable-debug --disable-stripping --extra-cflags='-fmessage-length=0 -O2 -Wall -D_FORTIFY_SOURCE=2 -fstack-protector -funwind-tables -fasynchronous-unwind-tables -g -fPIC -I/usr/include/gsm' --enable-gpl --enable-x11grab --enable-version3 --enable-pthreads --enable-avfilter --enable-libpulse --enable-libvpx --enable-libopus --enable-libass --enable-libmp3lame --enable-libvorbis --enable-libtheora --enable-libspeex --enable-libxvid --enable-libx264 --enable-libschroedinger --enable-libgsm --enable-libopencore-amrnb --enable-libopencore-amrwb --enable-postproc --enable-libdc1394 --enable-librtmp --enable-libfreetype --enable-avresample --enable-libtwolame
libavutil 51. 73.101 / 51. 73.101
libavcodec 54. 59.100 / 54. 59.100
libavformat 54. 29.104 / 54. 29.104
libavdevice 54. 2.101 / 54. 2.101
libavfilter 3. 17.100 / 3. 17.100
libswscale 2. 1.101 / 2. 1.101
libswresample 0. 15.100 / 0. 15.100
libpostproc 52. 0.100 / 52. 0.100

I hope it will help you.

With a recompiled version of rev362 I have now no problems, so I will not update any progam now!

meinereiner · 02-19-2013 21:56:29

Hello Dominique,

Packman has downgraded to ffmpeg 1.1 and updated to 1.0.4. In the vlc repository I also found a version with number 1.0.1.

So since the rev363 I can't compile with "actual" versions for opensuse your great program. The problem is still the same like I wrote before.

Do you have any suggestions for testing?

Greetings

Norbert

domledom · 02-20-2013 08:06:14

Hello Norbert

I'll try to take some time this weekend to look at this problem on suse.
Tell me, are there any packages for libav or libav-tools instead of ffmpeg?

meinereiner · 02-20-2013 10:22:21

Hello,

everywhere I searched there are actual only repositories with ffmpegversion <1.1 for opensuse.

I think its a problem in libavresample. There could be changes in the definition of some variables between 1.0.x and 1.1.x.

Greetings
Norbert

meinereiner · 02-24-2013 12:35:41

Hello,

Congratulation!

It compiles and run.

There's only a smal problem, but I think it's a problem of ffmpeg. Since packman has down/updated to 1.0.4 there is no support of aac anymore.

Great

Norbert

meinereiner · 02-24-2013 19:38:35

Hello again,

sorry the smal problem is not a ffmpeg problem. With version 362 it makes an mp4-file with aac-audio, with version 368 not.

In a terminal running this error is shown

[18:32:41.519:INFORMATION]      Sound hinzufügen
[18:32:41.520:ERROR]    Codec is experimental but experimental codecs are not enabled, try -strict -2
[18:32:41.520:ERROR]    EncodeVideo-OpenAudioStream: avcodec_open2() failed: Die Operation ist nicht erlaubt

Greetings

Norbert

domledom · 02-25-2013 08:01:48

Hello Norbert

Do you have libvo_aacenc installed on your computer?
Could you search for this package on packman?

Could you try this : In engine\_EncodeVideo.cpp file
Search this line (near line 644): } else if (Codec->id==AV_CODEC_ID_AAC) {
Add this after: AudioStream->codec->strict_std_compliance = FF_COMPLIANCE_EXPERIMENTAL;

meinereiner · 02-25-2013 17:37:07

Hello,

thanks for your quick answer.

libvo_aaenc isn't installed (and for compiling not necessary). packman has it in the reps.

After adding "AudioStream->codec->strict_std_compliance = FF_COMPLIANCE_EXPERIMENTAL;" and compiling and running there is a new error message:

[16:21:31.326:INFORMATION]      Sound hinzufügen
[16:21:31.326:ERROR]    Specified sample_fmt is not supported.
[16:21:31.326:ERROR]    EncodeVideo-OpenAudioStream: avcodec_open2() failed: Das Argument ist ungÃ¼ltig

domledom · 03-16-2013 14:31:58

Hello Norbert

I've just published packages of latest devel for openSUSE 12.2
Could you test them and confirm me they are working

Thanks in advance

meinereiner · 03-17-2013 12:27:10

Hello Dominique,

in the meantime I'va updated to opensuse 12.3. But in a second partitition 12.2 is sleeping for some tests.

So, your actual version is running...but...

Compiling is ok
Working progress is ok

Quality of video is ok
sound is NOT ok

When I export the soundtrack even also in the video there is a pulse on the sound. Whenyou have a silent slow music you can here a pulsate on the sound.

Pehrhaps you can confirm it.

Thanks and greetings

Norbert

domledom · 03-17-2013 12:31:35

Hello Norbert

I modify this morning the package for openSUSE. Now there are packages for version 12.2 and 12.3.
To limit space used on launchpad, I cut package into 2 parts (I hope users will not be afraid by that)
Could you test them ?

For the pulsate on sound, yes, I think I have a problem to solve and it appears in all plateforms.

meinereiner · 03-17-2013 13:26:13

Hello,

thanks for your fast request.

The problem is still the same. But I've found that this is a problem with the volume of the sound. Inserting a soundfile and stay the volume at 100% there is no pulse. Reducing the volume then you get the pulse. On my olde Project file I've reduced the Soundvolume to 40%, and at new tests there were no problem.

Greetings

meinereiner · 03-17-2013 14:25:30

And another bug is coming out now.

The timesynchronisation of sound an pictures didn't work.

In an mp4 video the next sound should begin at picture 85 on time 10:14 whre it is linked. But it begins at 9:40 at picture 80!

Greetings

#1 01-11-2013 20:25:49

Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#2 01-12-2013 07:00:13

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#3 01-13-2013 14:41:04

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#4 01-13-2013 16:44:54

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#5 01-18-2013 18:47:53

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#6 01-18-2013 20:48:33

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#7 01-18-2013 22:33:39

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#8 01-20-2013 15:47:36

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#9 01-20-2013 16:24:35

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#10 01-26-2013 12:09:05

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#11 01-27-2013 12:02:10

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#12 01-27-2013 16:53:54

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#13 01-27-2013 20:24:07

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#14 02-19-2013 21:56:29

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#15 02-20-2013 08:06:14

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#16 02-20-2013 10:22:21

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#17 02-24-2013 12:35:41

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#18 02-24-2013 19:38:35

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#19 02-25-2013 08:01:48

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#20 02-25-2013 17:37:07

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#21 03-16-2013 14:31:58

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#22 03-17-2013 12:27:10

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#23 03-17-2013 12:31:35

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#24 03-17-2013 13:26:13

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

#25 03-17-2013 14:25:30

Re: Audio conversion failed on opensuse12.2 with new ffmpeg 1.1

Board footer